Logo image
Restorative Narratives: Media Coverage of Ancestral Repatriation in Aotearoa New Zealand Print Media
Graduate Thesis/Dissertation   Open access

Restorative Narratives: Media Coverage of Ancestral Repatriation in Aotearoa New Zealand Print Media

Aislinn Hannah Wright Mirsch
Master of Science Communication - MSciComm, University of Otago
15/03/2025
Handle:
https://hdl.handle.net/10523/45259

Abstract

Repatriation Ancestral Remains Media Aotearoa New Zealand Germany Podcast

This thesis examines coverage and framing by Aotearoa New Zealand print media of

the international repatriation of Māori and Moriori Ancestral Remains from the start of the

government’s Karanga Aotearoa Repatriation Programme in 2003 until 2023. Using a mixed-

methods content and framing analysis approach, this study explores the implications of media

narratives surrounding colonialism, ethical responsibilities, and Indigenous representation.

Analysis was conducted of 120 news articles from three prominent newspapers: The New

Zealand Herald in Auckland, The Press in Christchurch, and The Dominion Post/The Post in

Wellington. Media coverage of repatriation fluctuated, with spikes in coverage predictably

occurring when there were dramatic or notable repatriation events. There were, however,

disparities in coverage of the international repatriation events from different countries. For

example, in answering a research question investigating Germany’s representation, the media

comparatively underrepresented repatriation events from Germany, revealing gaps in the

coverage. Just over half of the articles quoted Indigenous-identified sources, offering more in-

depth coverage in those cases. The choice of language in the media narratives either

acknowledged or did not reference the often violent colonial injustices surrounding the

acquisition of Ancestral Remains and the cultural importance of Indigenous-led repatriation

efforts. There was also diversity in the terminology used to describe the Ancestors, which points

towards an evolving framing of whether non-European human remains are framed in

objectifying or humanising ways. A complementary creative podcast was collaboratively

produced with Te Arikirangi Mamaku-Ironside of Kaea Consultancy. The podcast, featuring

Hinemoana Baker, provides listeners with context about repatriation from an Indigenous

perspective and an opportunity to connect to the people behind these efforts emotionally. This

thesis illustrates the role of media and storytelling in shaping the discourse of repatriation. It

advocates for ethical and inclusive narratives that acknowledge injustices of the past, the work

of activists today, and the potential for collaborative and cross-cultural reconciliation efforts in

the future.

pdf
Mirsch_MSciComm_Thesis_Dec20243.29 MBDownloadView
Open Access 1: Open Access

Metrics

1208 File views/ downloads
55 Record Views

Details

Logo image